#66 Business Model Breakdowns: Insurance I
Navigating Uncharted Waters: A Primer on Risk and Reward
Hello everyone, and welcome to our new series where we’re going to talk about business models. I'll be the first to say I'm no expert in these or any business models. Often, investors might shy away from certain models because they seem too complex or just plain daunting. But, as I've learned, sometimes the most complex things can be made simple with a bit of elbow grease and curiosity. We’ll keep it as simple and clear as possible - think of it like sitting down for a chat about business over a cup of coffee. So, here we are, ready to expand our circle of competence and delve into the nuts and bolts of various businesses. Understanding, say, the financials of an agricultural equipment company isn’t just about the tractors; it’s also about how they finance those big, green machines. That’s why we’re kicking things off with a sector that's as fundamental as it gets in the financial world: insurance.
Insurance companies are like the goalkeepers in the game of life – they're there to keep the unexpected at bay. These firms collect premiums and, in return, promise to protect you against those rainy days. Now, insurance comes in different flavors: Property and Casualty (P&C), Life and Health (L&H), and some smaller and niche ones, where each has its own playbook. P&C is about covering your tangible assets – think homes and cars. It’s short-term, unpredictable, and can sometimes feel like a roll of the dice. L&H, on the other hand, is more of a long game, dealing with life, health, and the certainty of uncertainty. Both have their quirks, from how they set aside money for future claims to how they make money from investing those hefty premiums they collect. And let’s not forget, insurance is a bit of a cyclical beast, with its ups and downs driven by competition and pricing.
So, grab a coffee as we'll look under the hood at what makes these companies tick, how they manage their money, and what tricks they might have up their sleeves. Stay tuned, because understanding insurance might just shed light on a whole lot more than you think.
If you enjoy Edelweiss Capital Research, then you should check out Shareholder Vote Exchange (SVE).
Owning stocks gives you the right to vote in major decisions that a company makes, such as choosing the board of directors or approving M&A deals. And yet, more than 80% of individual investors waste these valuable voting rights each year.
With SVE, you can now earn passive income by monetizing your unused shareholder votes. SVE enables investors to trade their voting rights, so passive investors can earn value from their votes, while engaged shareholders can have an outsized impact on corporate affairs.
✅ Register on SVE to start earning!
So, what exactly is insurance? In its simplest form, it’s a promise – a promise to protect you financially when the unexpected happens. Imagine you're carrying a fragile, incredibly valuable vase. If you drop it, you're out of luck. But what if you could pay a small amount to someone who promises to buy you a new one if it breaks?
Insurance companies are like those people who promise to replace your vase. They offer a safety net, allowing you to transfer the risk of financial loss to them in exchange for a fee, known as a premium. These companies step in to cover costs from events like car accidents, house fires, health emergencies, and even trips and falls. In return for taking on this risk, they charge you a premium – think of it as the price for your peace of mind.
But there's more to insurance than just collecting premiums. These companies are fascinating machines that balance risk, investment, and the need to make a profit. They are in the business of predicting the unpredictable, of putting a price tag on risk, and then investing the money they collect today to pay for the uncertainties of tomorrow.
Managing risk isn't just part of the business; it is the business.
How Insurance Companies Make Money
You might wonder how insurance companies turn a profit. Well, it boils down to two main streams: premiums and investments. When you pay your insurance premium, that money doesn't just sit in a vault gathering dust. Instead, it goes on a little journey, playing a part in a concept known as the 'float'.
The 'float' is the pool of money that an insurance company holds at any given time - premiums collected, but not yet paid out in claims. It's like a temporary loan that customers give to the insurance company, and here's the kicker - the insurer gets to use this money to make more money. They invest this float in various assets, and the income generated from these investments is a crucial part of their revenue. This is where the magic of the insurance business really happens.
The Underwriting Process
But before they can invest, they need to get the pricing right, and that's where underwriting comes in. Underwriting is the process of evaluating risk. It’s where insurers decide whether to insure you, and at what price. They look at a whole bunch of factors – like how risky it is to insure your house in a flood-prone area or your health if you’re a bungee-jumping enthusiast.
Each decision they make in underwriting is like placing a bet. If they price the risk right, they win by collecting more in premiums than they pay out in claims. Get it wrong, and it's like betting on the wrong horse - it can be costly. Good underwriters are like seasoned poker players; they know the odds and play the game smartly.
Investment of the Float
So, they’ve collected the premiums and have this pool of money – the float. What next? Well, insurance companies aren't just about covering risks; they're savvy investors too. They take this float and invest it in bonds, stocks, real estate, and other assets.
However, investing isn’t without its risks. The market can be as unpredictable as the weather. The goal here is to grow the float responsibly, ensuring that there’s always enough money to pay out claims, while also making a tidy sum to contribute to profits.
Investor's Lens: Key Indicators for good Insurers
1. Underwriting Profitability & Loss Reserving Practices
It's not just about how much they earn; it's about how wisely they manage their risks and money. There are a few key financial metrics and statements that are particularly telling.
Check the Loss Reserves: Imagine these as rainy-day funds. Companies estimate how much they might need to pay out in claims and set this money aside. It's a bit like packing an umbrella – you don't want to be caught in a storm unprepared. You should look for a company that’s prudent – not too conservative that they're sitting on a pile of unused cash, and not too optimistic to find themselves in a cash crunch. Never take things at face value, especially when it comes to insurance companies. They're often adept at tweaking their loss reserves – sometimes to cover past misjudgments, or other times to paint a rosy picture in a year that's been anything but. Many time these companies adjust their reserves to balance out the good years with the bad, or to soften the blow from the market's stern gaze in tough times.
This is why consistent judgment, or as I like to call it, 'steady-handedness', is undervalued in these firms. In the insurance industry, where the waters can get choppy, and they always will, this kind of stability in decision-making is worth its weight in gold.
Examine the Combined Ratio: This ratio is a measure of underwriting efficiency. It adds up the expenses and claim payments, and then divides them by the earned premiums. A ratio below 100% means they're earning more from premiums than they're spending – a solid indicator of underwriting proficiency. An insurance company must price policies accurately. The heart of their business lies in underwriting profitability – making more money from premiums than what's paid out in claims. Analyze their historical underwriting ratios to see how well they’ve played this balancing act over the years. A consistently low combined ratio is a good sign.
2. Float/Investment Portfolio
Understanding Capital Requirements for Different Investments: Nowadays, each type of investment comes with its own set of rules, particularly concerning capital requirements. For instance, more volatile investments such as stocks might require the company to hold more capital as a safety net, compared to more stable investments like government bonds. These regulations “ensure” that the company maintains enough buffer to protect its policyholders, even if its investments take a hit, but limite the discretion and freedom for a good investor to take the float investments to the next level.
Strategic Portfolio Management Within Constraints: In this regulated environment, how an insurance company manages its investment portfolio is more crucial than ever. It's a delicate balancing act. You can compare the returns of a bunch of peers over long term periods and see the differences.
3. Premium Growth and Pricing Strategies
As in any other company, pursuing expansion merely for the sake of becoming larger can often erode value rather than enhance it. True, sustainable growth is a strategic art – it should be measured, purposeful, and aligned with the core values and strengths of the company. Simply put, bigger isn't always better; smarter growth is.
Insurance companies need to price their policies accurately. They must assess risks meticulously and set premiums that are competitive yet profitable.
Venturing into New Markets: Insurance companies might explore untapped geographical regions or delve into new product lines. Each venture comes with its own set of risks and opportunities. The key is to understand these new markets deeply – their regulatory landscape, cultural nuances, and specific risk profiles. In the end, it is about assessing the management strategy, is it sound? Does it make sense? Have they proven they are capable to commit to their plans?
Adjusting Pricing in Response to Competition: Most insurance business operate in extremely competitive markets and often find themselves in a dance of pricing strategies. Companies need to be agile, responding to market dynamics with pricing that keeps them in the game without sacrificing underwriting standards.
In essence, when evaluating an insurance company’s premium growth and pricing strategies, look for signs of careful planning, market understanding, and a disciplined approach to risk management.
4. Thinking Beyond Insurance
Smart insurance companies are looking beyond the usual policies. They're diving into the ocean of data analytics and other innovative fields.
Harnessing Technology: How an insurer uses technology to improve their underwriting, customer service, and claims processing can be a real game-changer. It's like using a high-powered telescope instead of binoculars – you see clearer, further, and better. Many times these insurance businesses are hosting investor’s days where they explain more in depth how they are leveraging data and technology. Listen to them, are they talking bullshit, or do they show real tangible uses? Where are those impacting the numbers?
New Business Lines – A Sign of Good Management: In the insurance game, sticking to the old playbook won't win you championships anymore. The field's crowded, growth in the usual lanes is like squeezing water from a stone, and fierce competition is the name of the game. But here’s the twist – insurance companies sit on a gold mine of data. So, the million-dollar question is, are these companies looking beyond the usual insurance products? Are they tapping into data analytics or other uncharted territories?
Now, here's where the management team steps into the spotlight. If they can steer the company into new, profitable avenues without throwing resources down the drain, you’ve got yourself a dream team. It's about being shrewd with capital – spending it not just where it’s needed, but where it can work its magic.
Managing Cost Structures in a Commodity Market: when everyone is selling something similar, it's how cheaply you can sell your product that often counts. This is where being smart about costs comes in:
Look at Their Expense Ratio: This tells you how much they're spending to earn their money. It's a straightforward number. If an insurance company spends less to earn each dollar than most others, they're doing something right.
Cost Reduction Strategies: Are they using technology to make things more efficient? Are they handling claims in a smarter way? Look at past claims on (normally expensive) cost reduction programs. Did they work?
In essence, when you see an insurance company branching out smartly, making the most of their data, and exploring new markets without losing their grip on the core business, you’re looking at a management team that’s playing chess. They’re the kind of folks you want at the helm.
5. Take a look at the external environment
Regulatory Environment: In insurance rules matter a lot. New regulations can affect everything from how much capital an insurance company needs to how it must handle its policies. So, it's crucial to watch how these companies adapt to these changes. A company that navigates new regulations well can keep sailing smoothly, but one that struggles might start taking on water.
For instance, in the U.S., health insurers face a cap on their gross margins. It's a regulatory ceiling that ensures they don't earn too much at the expense of policyholders. But it's not just about rules on paper; political climates can sway regulations too. A political shift might bring in new rules aimed at cutting prices, without much regard for the long-term health of the industry. Keeping an eye on how a company navigates these regulatory waters, especially in turbulent times, can tell you a lot about its resilience.
Competitive Positioning: How an insurance company stands in the market tells you a bunch. Understanding where a company stands in terms of market share is important. Is it dominating the market, or is it just another player? Also, look at how they make themselves stand out. It's not just about size; it's about strength and strategy. Do they have a strong brand? Do they offer something unique? We are pretty sure if you compare all the insurance companies in a particular market, you will easily find out which ones stand out.
Some of the most interesting insurance firms operate in small niches. They might not dominate the broad market, but their focus on specialized areas can lead to exceptional returns on equity. These companies understand that being different, having a strong brand, or offering unique services can give them an edge.
Macro Factors: Economic, demography trends and interest rate fluctuations are like the wind and waves – they can either propel a company forward or make the journey rougher. Changes in the economy, like shifts in GDP growth or employment rates, can affect how many insurance policies people buy and what kind of policies they need. Interest rates are particularly crucial. Since insurance companies invest a large portion of their premiums, the returns they get are heavily influenced by these rates. When interest rates are high, they can earn more from their investments, boosting profitability, but these periods “often” coincide with tougher economic conditions like higher unemployment. So, it's a balancing act – good for investments but potentially bad for policy sales.
6. Quality of Earnings
To sum up, in assessing an insurance company's financial health, scrutinizing the quality of their earnings is critical.
Sustainability of Underwriting Profits: Sustainable underwriting profits are the bedrock of a good insurance company. They indicate not just a one-off success but an ongoing ability to assess and price risks accurately.
Reliability of Investment Income: Since insurance companies invest the premiums they collect, the income from these investments can significantly impact their bottom line. However, this shouldn't be a roller coaster of highs and lows (this is difficult to achieve if central banks continue playing their game of playing God). Nevertheless, you can always compare investment income returns among competitors. Is the one with the higher performance taking unreasonable risks? Consistent and stable investment income is a sign of a well-managed portfolio.
Accounting Practices and Reserve Management: Be cautious of accounting tricks. Some companies might shift costs to non-operating expenses to make their cost/premium ratios look better (specially if bonuses depend on particular intermediate metric). Similarly, watch how they handle their loss reserves. Are they playing with these numbers to meet short-term targets, only to suffer significant losses later? Historical trends can be telling a lot in this regard.
Long-Term Return on Equity (ROE): Long-term ROE is a crucial measure. It tells you how well a company is using its capital to generate profits. Look for consistent, strong ROE over time. It's a good indicator of a company's ability to generate value for shareholders in the long run, and it is easy and fast to get and compare.
Capital Adequacy: Adequate capital reserves are necessary not just for regulatory compliance but also for absorbing unexpected losses. A company that maintains a robust capital buffer is like a ship built to weather storms.
Additional Factors: Other factors to consider include the ratio of claims paid to premiums collected, administrative efficiency, and the company's track record in managing operational costs. All these contribute to a comprehensive view of the company's earning quality.
We've just scratched the surface of the insurance industry. It's not just about making money; it's about making smart, long-term decisions. Next time, we'll delve into the specialties of Property and Casualty (P&C) insurance versus Life and Health (L&H) insurance. Even if we have talked indistinctly so far, it's like comparing apples and oranges – similar, but with important differences. We'll unpack these differences in a straightforward way, giving you the nitty-gritty details you need to know.
If you enjoyed this piece, please give it a like and share!
Thanks for reading Edelweiss Capital Research! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support our work.
If you want to stay in touch with more frequent economic/investing-related content, give us a follow on Twitter @Edelweiss_Cap. We are happy to receive suggestions on how we can improve our work.
Nice post! I believe if you breakdown Private Equity/Asset Management industry it would be amazing content :)
Insurance has always been attractive to me because I knew Buffett made his billions by investing the insurance float.
Now I have better understanding of the business, great post mate!